In this extensive inquiry into the sources of modern selfhood, charles taylor demonstrates just how rich and precious those resources are. The book displays taylors mastery not only of the history of philosophy, but of theology, poetry, and art. Or else, we can think of the way much of our social planning, in crucial areas like risk as sessment, is dominated by forms of costbenefit analysis that involve grotesque calculations, putting dollar assessments on human lives. Charles taylor is here in search of a comprehensive understanding of what it means to be a human being, holding that only such an understanding as this can give moral philosophy the grounding it needs to operate persuasively and coherently. Charles taylor harvard university press cambridge, massachusetts. It is an attempt to articulate and to write a history of the modern identity. Human persons are self interpreting animals,1 but the materials and resources with which they interpret themselves change. Charles taylors latest work is undoubtedly one of the most significant works in. Pdf in his impressive and wideranging new book, sources of the self, charles taylor argues that modern moral philosophy, at least within the.
On the other hand, and perhaps more important, sources of the selfaims to contribute to the reconstruction of that same understanding of selfhood. Charles taylors sources of the self must we return to moral realism. An analogous point has been made in relation to blacks. In the process, taylor also greatly deepens his account of moral, political, and spiritual modernity that he had begun in sources of the self. Charles taylor, sources of the self russell hittinger i jln sources of the self, charles taylor proposes that modernity is much richer in moral resources than what its critics allow, though this richness is rendered invisible by the impoverished philosophical language of its most zealous defenders. Charles taylor against the negative sense of freedom.
Charles taylors sources of the selfhas at least two objectives. The major insight of sources of the self is that modern subjectivity, in all its epistemological, aesthetic, and political ramifications, has its roots in ideas of human good. Chmielewski develops the canadian philosophers intuitions, in which he finds similarities with other thinkers, and claims that the aesthetical is the genuine source. Sources of the self available for download and read online in other formats. The making of the modern identity harvard university press, 1989.
The making of the modern identity cambridge university press, 1989 from the back cover. Charles taylor, in full charles margrave taylor, born november 5, 1931, montreal, quebec, canada, canadian philosopher known for his examination of the modern self. Beginning with such old testament figures as abraham. With sources of the self canadian philosopher charles taylor has written a seminal work along the lines of ernst cassirers classic an essay on man.
Not everybody in the modern world will agree with the specific theistic interpretation taylor gives of these moral sources. But taylor insists that it is the exerciseconcept that comports with our intuition that freedom inevitably involves discriminations among our varying motivations. Building on charles taylor s sources of the self, this book explores lived christian identity through the ages. The making of the modern identity since its publication in 1989, charles taylors sources of the self has.
He has received many honors, including the templeton prize, the berggruen prize, and membership in the order of canada. More fruitful than further summary of taylor s historical epic might be a look at some of his philosophical premises and moral judgments. Charles taylor beyond this, they are condemned to suffer the pain of low self esteem. Pdf this is a big book from one of canadas preeminent philosophers. Michael rosen lincoln college, oxford in this paper i discuss taylor s criticism of contemporary moral philosophy and the role which this plays in his wider account of the development of western moral consciousness, an account which i. Michael rosen lincoln college, oxford in this paper i discuss taylors criticism of contemporary moral philosophy and the role which this plays in his wider account of the development of western moral consciousness, an account which i. Charles taylor quotes author of sources of the self. Those are the questions that charles taylor, a philosopher with a historical method, sets out to answer in sources of the self. Taylor was a candidate for the social democratic new democratic party ndp. A secular age charles taylor harvard university press.
The making of the modern identity is a work of philosophy by charles taylor, published in 1989 by harvard university press. Self expression is often called upon as a fundamental individual or collective right. Complete summary of charles taylor s the ethics of authenticity. How we have arrived at those values through centuries of struggle of advance and retreat, of hubris and doubt has never, in my mind, been more cogently described than in charles taylor s magisterial sources of the self. Charles taylor, sources of the self russell hittinger the. Charles taylors vision of modernity cambridge scholars. The making of the modern identity, which explored the multiplicity of the self, or the human subject, in the modern western world. Charles taylor gives a lecture at columbia university. The making of the modem identity cambridge, mass harvard university press, 1989, p. In this article, the author explores the anthropological and historical conditions that constitute self expression. Charles taylors sources of the self has at least two objectives. He produced a large body of work that is remarkable for its rangeboth for the number of areas and issues it addresses as well as for the breadth of scholarship it draws upon.
Unlike hegel, however, taylor does not see philosophy as the highest and truest expression of the. Charles taylor and the modern 121 charles taylor and the modern moral sources of the self mark joseph t. Htr the capacities relevant to freedom must involve some self awareness, self 6 charles taylor, the idea of freedom. Charles taylor s latest book sets out to define the modern identity by. He also shares georg wilhelm friedrich hegels commitment to synthesizing competing and conflicting elements of the culture.
Like charles taylor s earlier books, it is a product of prodigious erudition. Pdf a critique of charles taylors notions of moral. In his immense inquiry into the sources of modern selfhood, charles taylor reveals that modern subjectivity, in all its epistemological, aesthetic and political ramifications, has its roots in ideas of the human good. Carkner phd gordon carkner completed his doctorate in 2006 on the topic of a critical examination of the constitution of the moral self in michel foucault in dialogue with charles taylor through the university of wales, uk. On the one hand, it traces the historical sources of the modern understanding of selfhood. Sources of the self charles taylor harvard university. Charles taylor and the modern moral sources of the self. Sep 05, 2017 in this extensive inquiry into the sources of modern selfhood, charles taylor demonstrates just how rich and precious those resources are. In this paper i discuss taylors criticism of contemporary moral philosophy and the role. Michael rosen lincoln college, oxford in this paper i discuss taylor s criticism of contemporary moral philosophy and the role which this plays in his wider account of the development of western moral consciousness, an. Sources of the self charles taylor harvard university press. Charles taylor, sources of the self oxford handbooks. On the other hand, and perhaps more important, sources of the selfaims to contribute to the reconstruction of that same under standing of selfhood. On the debate between liberals and communitarians, see taylor s essay cross.
Deploring the minimal ethics of modernity and dissatisfied with postmodern nihilism, taylor positions his moral theory in the aristotelean tradition of ethos. Charles taylor, sources of self, ruth abbey, charles. A discussion of charles taylors sources of the self. The modern turn to subjectivity, with its attendant rejection of an objective order of reason, has ledit seems to manyto mere subjectivism at the mildest and to sheer nihilism at the worst. In this paper i argue that moral realism does not, pace charles taylor, need moral sources or constitutive goods, and adding these concepts distorts the basic insights of moral realism. Essays in honour of isiah berlin, ed alan ryan, oxford, 1979. Charles taylor is professor emeritus in the department of philosophy at mcgill university and author of influential books including sources of the self, the ethics of authenticity, and a secular age. Politics edit taylor was a candidate for the social democratic new democratic party ndp in mount royal on three occasions in the 1960s, beginning with the 1962 federal election when he came in. Pdf sources of the self download full pdf book download. Taylors philosophy instead tries to articulate moral sources that have the potential of empowering people to act morally and provide orientation to their lives. The canadian philosopher charles taylor has written two extended studies of what many people describe as modernity. Charles taylor on secularization ethical perspectives. Sources of the self is a work of moral philosophy which reaches beyond practical considerations concerning right and wrong.
On the debate between liberals and communitarians, see taylors essay cross. Alasdair macintyre, critical remarks on the sources of the. Buckley loyola college baltimore, maryland ecent theologians have widely argued or pve. Charles taylor and the sources of the self lincoln mullen. But i want to contend that taylor does not fully appreciate just how congenial they are to his 1 charles taylor, human agency and language, cambridge. Key concepts of charles taylors philosophy flashcards. Charles taylor s sources of the self the canadian philosopher charles taylor has written two extended studies of what many people describe as modernity.
Sources of the self is a work of scrupulous but not at all detached scholarship. From sources of the self to a secular age, charles taylor has shown how we create ways of being, as individuals and as a society. He has received many honors, including the templeton prize, the. This approach, taylor suggests, would allow for the sense of the dignity of human life, and the plurality of goods that constitute a good life. The self is a self only within a particular framework. Charles taylor s sources of the self must we return to moral realism. The making of the modern identity find, read and cite all the.
The language animal charles taylor harvard university press. The more recent of these books, a secular age 2007 examines the ways in which modern life became increasingly secularized or disenchanted. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. Most of us are still groping for answers about what makes life worth living, or what confers meaning on individual lives, writes charles taylor in sources of the self. Charles taylor s sources of the selfhas at least two objectives. After first arguing that contemporary philosophers have ignored how self and good connect, the author defines the modern identity by describing its genesis. Semantic scholar profile for charles taylor, with 243 highly influential citations and 301 scientific research papers. He is attempting nothing less than a synthesis of moral reflection with intellectual history. His book is an investigation of how the modern sense of what it means to be a person came into being through the influences of.
Many critics believe that the modern order has no moral. Charles taylor and ethical naturalism university of ottawa. The making of modern identity, attempts to articulate the goods that ground our sense of why life is worth living while also showing how this entails a commitment to specific moral aims and principles. Hereafter, this work will be cited parenthetically in the text by page number.
Charles taylor, a professor of political science and philosophy at mcgill university in montreal, maintains that a persons sense of self and of how that self may be related to other selves, to. Taylor would begin instead with what heidegger would call beingintheworld and take life experience, before reduction to a scientific approach, as the source for understanding the self. Here, he demonstrates that language is at the center of this generative process. Charles, 1931the ethics of authenticity i charles taylorl. Charles taylor s latest book sets out to define the modern identity by tracing its genesis, analysing the writings of such thinkers as augustine, descartes, montaigne, luther, and. In that book taylor sweeps western ethical history to reveal a succession of moral visions and ideals from the battle. Charles taylors vision of modernity ix together with it the problem of morality and of politics. Rather, taylor wants us to see that there is a moral ideal behind the idea of authenticity. The book displays taylor s mastery not only of the history of philosophy, but of theology, poetry, and art.
Pdf morality, identity, and historical explanation. Synopsis most of us are still groping for answers about what makes life worth living, or what confers meaning on individual lives, writes charles taylor in sources of the self. Charles taylor thinks that it is a mistake to believe that the culture of authenticity is simply a screen for self indulgence 16. The more recent of these books, a secular age 2007 examines the ways in which modern life became.
888 1533 970 77 1654 1052 1173 220 152 1415 1587 803 523 567 4 733 1571 24 620 1307 1496 1250 1354 952 280 810 327 1089 1468 1029 788 508 1003 1432 843 192